← Volver a la portada
África · Actualidad general · Daily Maverick

ConCourt’s elections judgment again raises questions of inconsistency

Publicado por Daily Maverick · Sudáfrica hace 10 h
Former chief justice Sandile Ngcobo. (Photo: Daniel Born / The Times / Gallo Images)
Former chief justice Sandile Ngcobo. (Photo: Daniel Born / The Times / Gallo Images) · Daily Maverick

Resumen detallado

The Constitutional Court’s decision to overturn the Electoral Court’s ruling on the ANC’s incomplete 2026 local election candidate submissions undermines the rule of law and…

The Constitutional Court’s decision to overturn the Electoral Court’s ruling on the ANC’s incomplete 2026 local election candidate submissions undermines the rule of law and public trust in the judiciary.

Judith February is executive officer at Freedom Under Law and Chris Oxtoby is a research associate at Freedom Under Law.

Writing in 2018, academic Leo Boonzaier commented gloomily on the state of the Constitutional Court’s jurisprudence:

“No follower of the court’s judgments can fail to have noticed a decline in their quality. […] Over the last few years they [the court’s judges] have grown increasingly unaccountable to the legal and academic communities, to the law (including their own precedents), and even to logic and argumentation. […]”

Similar concerns regarding the consistency and quality of the court’s judgments have continued to be made. Boonzaier made these comments in the course of an analysis of a judgment on the specific issue of how state officials could seek judicial review of their own decisions. But concerns about the coherence of the court’s judgments have spanned a wide range of fields of law.

The Constitutional Court’s recent decision in the case between the ANC and the Electoral Commission, decided shortly before the 2026 local elections, seems on the face of it to raise similar concerns about its consistency with our jurisprudence.

One caveat is immediately required – the court has not yet handed down the reasons for its decision. (This in itself raises a different set of questions about the efficiency of the court’s operations, but that is a different topic). Does this make criticism of the decision unfair? Not necessarily.

To recap briefly on the background of the case. The Electoral Commission had ruled that certain party lists and ward candidate nominations had not been validly submitted by the ANC before the statutory deadline. The information had been uploaded, but the portal’s “submit as final” function had not been clicked.

The ANC challenged…

Inicio del artículo, extracto de Daily Maverick. Para leer el resto, abra el artículo en el sitio del medio.

Leer el artículo completo en Daily Maverick Inicie sesión para guardar

MarketNews muestra el titular y el resumen publicados por el medio. El artículo completo se lee en el sitio del editor. (www.dailymaverick.co.za)

También te puede interesar