‘Hindsight is a wonderful thing’: The draft selections your club would want over
Resumen detallado
Your AFL club’s recruiting and list-management teams put their reputations on the line this week when the AFL national draft begins on Thursday. There will be hits, but also likely misses – as history attests.
For all the deep-dive physical and mental analysis that AFL recruiting departments conduct on prospective recruits, drafting remains an inexact science.
While clubs have plenty of hits, there are misses. We take a look at selections that didn’t quite work out since 2011, when Gold Coast joined the competition.
The choice: 2019. Fischer McAsey (pick six) over Caleb Serong (pick eight), Kysaiah Pickett (pick 12) and Cody Weightman (pick 15).
The fallout: Adelaide took the highly rated Vic Metro backman (he was named Vic Metro’s player of the 2019 championships ahead of Matt Rowell and Noah Anderson) during a major rebuild, hoping he would emerge as a key intercept defender. However, McAsey struggled to have an impact, managing just 10 games before quitting after the 2023 campaign, later acknowledging he lost the “spark” in his final two years. “For whatever reason, I didn’t feel good going into training a lot of the time,” McAsey said.
The choice: 2015. Josh Schache (pick two) over Harry McKay (pick 10) and Charlie Curnow (pick 12).
The fallout: Schache, whose late father Laurence played for the Brisbane Bears in the early 1990s, was drafted with high expectations as a marquee key forward, the Murray Bushrangers product seen as a successor to Jonathan Brown. But he managed only 27 games for the Lions before he was traded to the Western Bulldogs in the dying stages of the 2017 trade period for picks 25 and 40. He logged 45 games in five seasons for the Dogs, and four with Melbourne, never fulfilling his high draft billing. Eventual Coleman medallists McKay and Curnow were snapped by Carlton, and remain key pieces with the Blues and Sydney, respectively.
The choices: 2017. Paddy Dow (pick three) over Luke Davies-Uniacke (pick four) and Aaron Naughton (pick nine); 2017. Lochie O’Brien (pick 10) over Zac Bailey (pick 15), Ed Richards (pick 16) and Jack Higgins (pick 17).
The fallout: Carlton hoped Dow and O’Brien would form part of a premiership midfield alongside Patrick…
Inicio del artículo, extracto de The Age. Para leer el resto, abra el artículo en el sitio del medio.
MarketNews muestra el titular y el resumen publicados por el medio. El artículo completo se lee en el sitio del editor. (www.theage.com.au)


