← Volver a la portada
Oceanía · Actualidad general · The Conversation AU

NZ’s pay equity law has been found to breach women’s rights. How can it stand?

Publicado por The Conversation AU · Australia hace 1 h
Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images
Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images · The Conversation AU

Resumen detallado

A High Court ruling points to a major vulnerability in NZ’s democracy: when parliament passes discriminatory laws under urgency, the courts can’t overturn them.

The High Court has ruled New Zealand’s 2025 pay equity reforms unjustifiably discriminate against women.

Yet the law remains in force. And the government is under no legal obligation to reverse the changes. How can that be?

The answer goes beyond pay equity. The judgement exposes a wider vulnerability in New Zealand’s system of human rights protection: what happens when parliament itself passes legislation that breaches fundamental rights?

New Zealand has a single-chamber parliament, permissive rules for passing legislation under urgency, and courts that cannot invalidate laws simply because they breach the Bill of Rights Act.

The pay equity case demonstrates what happens when these features come together.

The challenge against the government’s overhaul of the Equal Pay Act in May 2025 was brought by five unions representing workers in predominantly female occupations, including nursing, education and public services.

Equal pay means men and women receive the same pay for doing the same job. Pay equity goes further: it means equal pay for work of equal value, even when the jobs are different. It aims to address the historical undervaluation of work predominantly performed by women.

Our earlier analysis shows why this matters. Women have moved into traditionally male professions in large numbers, but men have not moved into female-dominated occupations to the same extent. Professions like nursing and care work remain overwhelmingly female.

When entire occupations are undervalued, equal pay within those jobs does not address wider gender pay gaps.

Inicio del artículo, extracto de The Conversation AU. Para leer el resto, abra el artículo en el sitio del medio.

Leer el artículo completo en The Conversation AU Inicie sesión para guardar

MarketNews muestra el titular y el resumen publicados por el medio. El artículo completo se lee en el sitio del editor. (theconversation.com)

También te puede interesar