← Volver a la portada
Estados Unidos · Actualidad general · The Boston Globe

Olivia Rodrigo is not a plagiarist

Publicado por The Boston Globe · Estados Unidos hace 10 h
Olivia Rodrigo is not a plagiarist
The Boston Globe

Resumen detallado

The Waitresses absolve Olivia Rodrigo of borrowing a vibe from “Christmas Wrapping.” But copyright law shouldn’t require permission for inspiration.

R.J. Lehmann is the editor in chief of the International Center for Law & Economics.

Chris Butler of the Waitresses, the ’80s New Wave band, has an early Christmas gift for Olivia Rodrigo: He loves her new holiday song — and has no intention of suing her for plagiarism.

Butler wrote the Waitresses’ quirky, herky-jerky classic “Christmas Wrapping.” It always moves into heavy rotation as the days grow shorter and colder, but this year some listeners thought they heard it more often than usual — especially in Rodrigo’s new “Take Me Home (4 Christmas).”

Rodrigo’s instant smash earned more than 765,000 streams in its first week. While her affection for ’80s alt-rock icons is well known — Rodrigo’s new album not only has a song called “The Cure” but has a duet with that band’s singer, Robert Smith — her new Christmas song’s conversational vocals, brisk rhythm, and wry treatment of pre-Christmas romance struck some listeners as more than homage.

Stereogum and others reported on accusations of improper borrowing. (Rodrigo is no stranger to those.) On social media, fans demanded that the rising icon award the faded New Wave star a songwriting credit.

Yet Butler, who also wrote the hit “I Know What Boys Like,” did not want any credit at all. On his Facebook page, he explained that Rodrigo had emailed him before her song was released and that he welcomed and appreciated the tribute. “I think it’s a fantasticbangersmash,” he wrote, “and if it has the same upbeat vibe as ’CW,’ well … how cool is that?”

The list of artists who have found themselves in court is filled with Rock and Roll Hall of Famers. Radiohead, themselves targeted by the Hollies over “Creep,” later reached a settlement with Lana del Rey when they believed “Get Free” came too close to their first hit.

In this case, Butler concluded that a shared vibe was more like flattery. Guitar transcriptions of “Christmas Wrapping” and “Take Me Home (4 Christmas)” suggest that the two songs share a tonal center — the note that…

In…

Inicio del artículo, extracto de The Boston Globe. Para leer el resto, abra el artículo en el sitio del medio.

Leer el artículo completo en The Boston Globe Inicie sesión para guardar

MarketNews muestra el titular y el resumen publicados por el medio. El artículo completo se lee en el sitio del editor. (www.bostonglobe.com)

También te puede interesar