← Retour à la une
Asie · Actualité générale · Rappler

[Puso at Diwa] A lost opportunity to test the truth in Sara Duterte’s trial

Publié par Rappler · Philippines il y a 47 min
[Puso at Diwa] A lost opportunity to test the truth in Sara Duterte’s trial
Rappler

Résumé détaillé

The withdrawal of witnesses may be a tactical decision for the defense. But for the Filipino people, it is also a lost opportunity to test the truth.

There is something unsettling about a trial in which witnesses initially identified by one side suddenly disappear from the witness stand.

The defense of Vice President Sara Duterte has withdrawn 18 of the 24 witnesses it initially listed before the Senate impeachment court. Among them were 16 bank executives from eight financial institutions, including BPI, BDO, LandBank, Metrobank, PSBank, Security Bank, EastWest and UnionBank. Other witnesses, including former law dean Ralph Sarmiento and Quezon City Prosecutor Vimar Barcellano, were also dropped.

Some testimony, it said, was no longer necessary or could be covered by stipulation. In the case of BPI senior vice president Paul Roderick Ysmael, counsel explained that his purpose was merely to authenticate a letter whose authorship had already been acknowledged in open court. The testimony of Prosecutor Barcellano was likewise dispensed with after the prosecution agreed to stipulate to the authenticity of the public documents he was expected to identify. (READ: [Puso at Diwa] Foreign currency deposit secrecy: Time for a constitutional rethink)

But an impeachment trial is not an ordinary dispute between private parties. It is a constitutional proceeding involving one of the country’s highest elected officials. Ultimately, it is the Filipino people who must live with the consequences of the Senate’s judgment.

That is why the withdrawal of witnesses deserves attention beyond courtroom strategy.

A witness may help the defense, hurt the defense, or reveal something neither side expected. That is precisely why witnesses are examined and cross-examined.

The prosecution wanted to question Ysmael about bank records and an alleged dollar account involving the Vice President. Prosecutors cited a BPI letter indicating that Duterte had dollar accounts and said they wanted to clarify the records and circumstances surrounding them. But the witness was withdrawn before they could ask those questions.

That matters because the prosecution…

T…

Début de l'article, extrait de Rappler. Pour lire la suite, ouvrez l'article chez le média.

Lire l'article complet sur Rappler Connectez-vous pour sauvegarder

MarketNews présente le titre et le résumé publiés par le média. L'article complet se lit sur le site de l'éditeur. (www.rappler.com)

À lire aussi