I expected juicy gossip. I didn’t expect one of the year’s best memoirs
Detailed summary
“Whoever tells the story first controls the narrative,” writes Sofia Franklyn in Daddy Issues, her memoir detailing her own side of her spectacular exit from the hit podcast Call…
“Whoever tells the story first controls the narrative,” writes Sofia Franklyn in Daddy Issues, her memoir detailing her own side of her spectacular exit from the hit podcast Call Her Daddy. For Franklyn, it’s a hard-won insight.
It’s widely known as the “biggest podcast fumble in history” – Franklyn ostensibly bungling herself out of a deal that her one-time partner, Alex Cooper, has spun into a $US500 million media and lifestyle empire, the Unwell Network. Franklyn has been on the losing end of the public narrative ever since.
The fallout was initially framed by Cooper, who in 2020 posted a slick video telling the podcast’s #DaddyGang fans that Franklyn’s greed, laziness and subservience to a man (her boyfriend at the time, HBO executive Peter Nelson, the book’s tragic collateral damage) were to blame for their split. It was then cemented by the pair’s original boss, Barstool Sports kingpin Dave Portnoy, who framed Franklyn as a messy, entitled brat in his tacky memoir (please, let us never speak of it again), Cancel Me If You Can.
Franklyn’s late entry – revenge served ice-cold – spins another perspective to the saga, detailing Cooper’s behind-the-scenes backstabbing and calculated manoeuvring. She frames Cooper as a Gatsby-meets-Brutus character: secretive, unreliable, a ruthless social climber who’d mysteriously cut ties with her past.
Of course, it was all good at first. Early scenes highlight their sisterly (almost sapphic, Franklyn implies) camaraderie as Manhattan transplants. Later chapters drop in digs that explain the book’s opening revelation that Cooper’s husband, Matt Kaplan, called Franklyn’s publisher saying Cooper was threatening to sue before the book was even written. “It’s the first I’ve heard from Alex in six years. The first since the fallout, when she stopped responding to my text messages,” writes Franklyn.
The icky, enticing dirty laundry is worth the price of admission. And Franklyn is such a thoughtful and emotive writer, naturally comfortable…
Opening of the article, excerpted from The Sydney Morning Herald. To read the rest, open the article on the publisher's site.
MarketNews shows the headline and summary published by the outlet. The full article is on the publisher's website. (www.smh.com.au)

