"Hawks Flying In Formation": Judge Refuses To Toss DRAM Cartel Suit Against Samsung, SK Hynix And Micron, Opening Door To Discovery

Detailed summary
"Hawks Flying In Formation": Judge Refuses To Toss DRAM Cartel Suit Against Samsung, SK Hynix And Micron, Opening Door To Discovery For the past year, the only people with the…
For the past year, the only people with the power to do anything about memory prices have been the three companies that set them. As of this weekend, a federal judge in San Jose has joined the list.
Regular readers know we have spent most of 2026 chronicling what soaring memory prices have done to everything they touch: PC shipments in January, producer prices in June, Apple's price list shortly after, and by July the Fed itself, when we reported that Goldman saw AI-driven memory, software and electricity costs adding 0.5% to core PCE by year-end. Well, year-end is six weeks away, memory prices are still in orbit, and the question of why supply never showed up is now officially a matter for discovery.
In an order dated Nov. 14, Judge Noël Wise of the Northern District of California denied in full the joint motion by Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron (MU) to dismiss the proposed class action accusing the three of conspiring to choke off the supply of conventional DRAM. The decision finds that the complaint plausibly alleges an agreement in violation of Section 1 of the Sherman Act. That is a long way from a finding of guilt, but it does mean the Big Three now have to answer the complaint by December 7 and then start handing over documents.
The case, Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics, was filed on June 25 by 17 plaintiffs from five states (14 consumers and three small PC builders) on behalf of indirect purchasers, i.e., anyone who bought a device with commodity DRAM inside it. They want class status, an injunction and treble damages.
The defense was simple, and it had worked before. A near-identical suit filed in 2018 over the 2016-2018 price spike was thrown out in 2020, and the Ninth Circuit affirmed in March 2022 on the grounds that three rivals cutting output at the same time looked like ordinary, unchoreographed oligopoly behavior.
The memorable part came at the hearing, when the defendants reached for the late Judge Richard Posner's old line that rivals in concentrated…
Opening of the article, excerpted from ZeroHedge. To read the rest, open the article on the publisher's site.
MarketNews shows the headline and summary published by the outlet. The full article is on the publisher's website. (www.zerohedge.com)



