← Retour à la une
Océanie · Actualité générale · The Conversation AU

Can the police monitor a suspect’s brain during interrogation? A new report issues a stark warning

Publié par The Conversation AU · Australie il y a 2 h
GettyImages
GettyImages · The Conversation AU

Résumé détaillé

Some forces are using neurotechnology devices to determine if suspects have ‘guilty knowledge’, raising concerns over human rights violations.

If you were arrested as a suspect in in a murder case, could the police make you put on a brain-monitoring device and then use evidence derived from it to try to convict you?

These questions are among many being examined in a new report on the use of neurotechnology in criminal justice settings, jointly published by INTERPOL and the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime this month.

Neurotechnology is an umbrella term for emerging technologies that are able to read and decode information from the body’s neural system. These technologies range from cochlear implants to brain-computer interfaces, which can transfer a person’s thoughts to an external device.

Advances in neurotechnology that is not implanted have increasingly raised ethical and legal concerns about usage in non-medical settings, such as police interrogations. In a report one of us (Allan McCay) co-authored last year, we argued neural devices had been insufficiently tested to determine whether they actually work in criminal justice settings.

Yet, some police forces around the world, such as in the United Arab Emirates and India, are already using the technology when interviewing suspects to determine if they have “guilty knowledge” of a crime.

Researchers say this technology differs from a traditional lie detection test because of the potential to reveal the “fingerprint” of knowledge within the brain.

For example, a device called an EEG headset can be placed on the head of a suspect who is then shown a photo of the crime scene. The device’s sensors can then detect neural activity associated with recognition. The claim is the suspect may involuntarily betray their guilty knowledge.

Another technique employs neural lie detectors in suspect interrogations. These are purportedly able to detect brain activity associated with lying. There are no reports of police currently using this technology.

The new report argues neither approach has been scientifically proven to be effective.

Début de l'article, extrait de The Conversation AU. Pour lire la suite, ouvrez l'article chez le média.

Lire l'article complet sur The Conversation AU Connectez-vous pour sauvegarder

MarketNews présente le titre et le résumé publiés par le média. L'article complet se lit sur le site de l'éditeur. (theconversation.com)

À lire aussi