Do youth boot camps reduce crime? What the evidence says about ‘tough love’ for troubled youths

Résumé détaillé
Both of Victoria’s major parties are promising to introduce tough programs aimed at addressing youth crime. Will they work?
With Victoria’s state election less than two weeks away, both major parties have proposed new ways to address youth crime and improve community safety.
Opposition Leader Jess Wilson has proposed introducing youth justice boot camps, while Labor Premier Ben Carroll has announced a $204 million mandatory rehabilitation scheme
What does the evidence tell us about whether these approaches actually work?
The Coalition proposes converting the former Dhurringile Prison, near Shepparton in northern Victoria, into a boot camp for offenders aged 14 to 17. The prison closed in 2024 due to a drop in demand for minimum-security beds.
Under Wilson’s plan, courts could send young people there instead of imposing a community corrections order or another custodial sentence.
Participants would follow strict daily routines involving farm work, cleaning, maintenance, cooking and education.
Wilson said the program would instil discipline and respect, teach practical skills and give young offenders a second chance.
Under Labor’s proposed “mandatory therapeutic orders”, young people convicted of lower and mid-level offences (including theft, property damage and minor assaults) could be detained in secure residential facilities for up to 12 months.
They would be required to participate in education, drug and alcohol treatment, mental health support and practical life skills programs.
Début de l'article, extrait de The Conversation AU. Pour lire la suite, ouvrez l'article chez le média.
MarketNews présente le titre et le résumé publiés par le média. L'article complet se lit sur le site de l'éditeur. (theconversation.com)


