Election 2026: Electoral experts, former PM warn of need for changes to MMP after overhang results

Detailed summary
A group of electoral experts, including a former Prime Minister, is calling for consideration of changes to “safeguard MMP” in the future, arguing the 2026 election has “exposed a…
A group of electoral experts, including a former Prime Minister, is calling for consideration of changes to “safeguard MMP” in the future, arguing the 2026 election has “exposed a significant weakness” in the settings.
In an open letter issued today, the figures write this year’s vote has shown a “breakdown, both accidental and deliberately engineered”, in the mixed member proportional (MMP) system.
“The 2026 election preliminary results would give the second-place party six more MPs than the party with the most party votes,” the letter says.
“Another party has five times the number of MPs its party vote would allocate to it. These are not proportional outcomes and they give more power to some voters over others.”
Some ideas for changing MMP are raised in the letter, including increasing the number of list MPs or reducing the number of electorate MPs, or adjusting a party’s voting strength in Parliament to reflect their party vote and not the number of MPs they have.
Among the letter’s 46 signatories are former Prime Minister Sir Geoffrey Palmer, chairman of the 2023 independent electoral review; Deborah Hart, former Electoral Commission chairwoman; 2012 MMP review chairman Sir Hugh Williams; and a number of academics specialising in electoral and constitutional matters.
Addressed to members of the new Parliament, the authors call on all political parties to commit to adjusting the MMP system’s settings “to safeguard proportionality”.
The issue of whether MMP is working as intended has been put into the spotlight by the 2026 election preliminary results – to be confirmed with final results next week – showing National and Te Pāti Māori winning more seats than their party vote result entitled them to.
Under MMP, voters have two votes – one for an electorate representative and a second for a political party. It’s intended that a party receives roughly the same proportion of seats in Parliament as it receives in the party vote.
Opening of the article, excerpted from NZ Herald. To read the rest, open the article on the publisher's site.
MarketNews shows the headline and summary published by the outlet. The full article is on the publisher's website. (www.nzherald.co.nz)


