← Retour à la une
Afrique · Actualité générale · Daily Maverick

Treasury says industry claims of 16,000-plus job losses from sugar tax unverified

Publié par Daily Maverick · Afrique du Sud il y a 16 h
Treasury says industry claims of 16,000-plus job losses from sugar tax unverified
Treasury says industry claims of 16,000-plus job losses from sugar tax unverified · Daily Maverick

Résumé détaillé

The sugar industry has repeatedly pointed to a Nedlac-commissioned assessment to support its claim that the Health Promotion Levy cost thousands of jobs. But the figure has never…

The sugar industry has repeatedly pointed to a Nedlac-commissioned assessment to support its claim that the Health Promotion Levy cost thousands of jobs. But the figure has never been verified against actual employment records, and other research has reached different conclusions.

The figure of 16,621 has become a key part of the sugar industry’s campaign against South Africa’s sugar tax. It appears in an economic assessment Wesbound prepared for Nedlac, which estimated that employment across the economy was lower in 2019 than it would have been in a hypothetical scenario without the levy.

The National Treasury has since confirmed that the figure is a modelled estimate, meaning it was calculated using assumptions about how the levy would affect consumer behaviour, sugar demand, production, employment and the wider economy, not a count of people confirmed to have lost their jobs.

The Wesbound assessment used a computable general equilibrium model to estimate how the levy affected economic activity, production and employment. It compared the economy with the levy against a modelled scenario in which the levy had not been introduced.

The report’s estimate therefore depends on the assumptions and information used to construct those scenarios. It does not establish that 16,621 identifiable workers lost their jobs, or that the levy was the sole reason for employment changes in the industries concerned.

The National Treasury’s response to questions from Daily Maverick confirmed that the figure should not be understood as an audited count.

“The figure does not represent an audited count of actual jobs lost, but rather a modelled estimate based on a set of assumptions regarding behavioural responses, sugar demand, production patterns, employment relationships and broader economic linkages,” the Treasury said.

The department also said it was “not aware of independently verified employment data demonstrating that exactly 16,621 jobs were lost as a direct result of the HPL”.

The…

Début de l'article, extrait de Daily Maverick. Pour lire la suite, ouvrez l'article chez le média.

Lire l'article complet sur Daily Maverick Connectez-vous pour sauvegarder

MarketNews présente le titre et le résumé publiés par le média. L'article complet se lit sur le site de l'éditeur. (www.dailymaverick.co.za)

À lire aussi